Welcome to Cala Lily Restaurant and Bar
Cala Lily Restaurant and Bar, nestled in Gibsonia, PA, is an exceptional culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Known for its intimate atmosphere and attentive service, the restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its meticulous attention to detail. Guests frequently highlight the extraordinary seabass, prepared with a macadamia nut crust and cherry glaze, setting a benchmark for seafood lovers. The extensive cocktail menu, featuring creative martinis, complements the exquisite menu, which includes standout dishes like lobster-stuffed ravioli and Cajun pork chops. Despite its modest exterior, Cala Lily delivers top-tier food and hospitality, making it a must-visit for any food enthusiast.
Cala Lily Restaurant and Bar: Reviews & Ratings
One of the best restaurant experiences I've had around Pittsburgh. I really couldn't complain about much me anything here! Hope to see you guys again soon!
We love to sit at the bar and have our meals. The bar tenders are always so friendly & talkative to us. Makes us feel welcome. AND....let me tell you about the seabass!! I've ate it different places & it NEVER compares to how their chef prepares it! NO WHERE!! Larry & Lori
We hadn't been to Cala Lily since pre-pandemic. We recalled it being a good meal and a pleasant experience so we decided to go back for our anniversary. Wow! It was just outstanding. Service was great. Tables were close but didn't seem intrusively so. There listed nearly 20 interesting martinis at 10 each. But the food-omg. We started with meatballs and mushrooms which were tastier than any appetizer I recall having in the past. Dinner salads were just right and there aren't enough superlatives to describe the entrees. First of all, they looked great on the plates. We had salmon from the menu which was yummy and an off-the-menu special Chilean sea bass. The sea bass was made with a macadamia nut entrusting and covered in a cherry glaze which included actual cherries. OK, the sea bass was expensive at 58 but it was out of this world. I order sea bass whenever it's available so I've had it often but this treatment was unlike anything I've ever had. I had intended to get some kind of steak but, when I heard the server describe the sea bass, I had to try it. We cannot wait to go back to see their next batch of specials.
What a GREAT PLACE: excellent food (the absolute best in the greater Pittsburgh area in my humble opinion), really, really good service (by the most attentive and courteous Elly), and a really nice atmosphere. Food: Since we are geezers and live about an hour away, we went for the early bird special. Our reservation was for 5:00 and we were promptly seated by a courteous hostess. Elly apprised us of the daily specials of which there were quite a few. She spoke expertly about them all. Colleen had the lobster stuffed ravioli served with gulf shrimp in a silky pink leek sauce with pine nuts. FANTASTIC! I had the Cajun pork chop, peppercorned and served with stuffed banana peppers and tomatoe sauce. Also FANTASTIC as well as spicy - yum. The chop was 1" thick and could not have been better cooked. Both came with different and equally delicious mixed vegetables. (These veggies were perfectly cooked.) Service: From the hostess to Elly to the other assistants everyone was attentive and proficient. Service truly is EXCELLENT. Atmosphere: The place is quite small but is tastefully appointed with large mirrors, brick and wood to create a pleasant environment for dining. HIGHLY, HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Cala Lily is a small restaurant in a very small strip mall, but don't let that fool you. We've dined there twice and the food and service were absolutely top-notch both times.
We discovered this restaurant by chance, it’s not advertised and it’s pretty hidden back by target in Gibsonia. But I’m so glad we found it! They are always busy with Loyal customers and their food is amazing and so consistent. Out of 10 would recommend especially their martinis.
The food is some of the best that I have ever had. The chef makes everything, and it is delicious. I had lobster stuffed ravioli with shrimp in a creamy pink sauce with shallots. The soup was lobster bisque.
This place has amazing food and service. The atmosphere is great as well. You'll need to make a reservation, because the seating area is quite small, but aside from that, it was a perfect experience.
Location
-
500 Grandview Crossing #20, Gibsonia, PA 15044, United States Hotline: +1 724-502-4572
If you find yourself in Gibsonia, PA, make it a point to visit the charming Cala Lily Restaurant and Bar, where exceptional dining experiences await. Located at 500 Grandview Crossing #20, this small yet welcoming establishment has made a stellar impression on locals and visitors alike, garnering rave reviews for its mouthwatering cuisine and warm, attentive service.
One standout feature of Cala Lily is its strong focus on quality ingredients and expertly crafted dishes. Many patrons have praised the restaurant for its remarkable seabass, declaring it the finest they've ever encountered. One customer, Lori Nicastro, raves about the seabass’s unparalleled preparation, highlighting its unique culinary treatment that sets it apart from competitors. This attention to detail is echoed in other dishes—like the lobster-stuffed ravioli and Cajun pork chop—both of which have received equal accolades for their rich flavors and beautiful presentations. As Eli Shaheen noted, the seabass—though at a premium price of $58—is described as a “once-in-a-lifetime” dish, rich with a flavorful macadamia nut crust and a delightful cherry glaze.
The atmosphere at Cala Lily also deserves a mention. Despite its location in a modest strip mall, the ambiance is anything but ordinary. Guests are welcomed by a tastefully designed interior that combines classic brick and wood features with a cozy layout. This creates an intimate dining environment ideal for celebrating special occasions, as noted by Eli, who returned for his anniversary and left utterly impressed by the experience.
Service at Cala Lily is consistently highlighted in reviews, with customers remarking on the warm, engaging demeanor of the staff. Whether you choose to sit at the bar or a table, you’ll feel like a valued guest rather than just another customer. This welcoming atmosphere is complemented by an extensive martini menu that adds to the overall dining experience, allowing you and your companions to unwind and savor every moment.
In conclusion, Cala Lily Restaurant and Bar is a hidden gem in the greater Pittsburgh area. With its commitment to outstanding food, charming ambiance, and impeccable service, it promises an unforgettable dining experience. Don't just take my word for it—plenty of satisfied diners attest to the magic of this culinary sanctuary. So gather your friends or make a date night out of it, and prepare to indulge in some of the best flavors Gibsonia has to offer.
For more information, or to make a reservation, give them a call at +1 724-502-4572.